I wrote this sophomore year for a fiction workshop. Let me know what you think? :)
Driving With Strange Boys
I had hardly gotten in the car before George asked me what I wanted to do with the rest of my life. I don’t know why that’s such a common question. You would think people would find it personal, maybe at least ask you about how many pets and siblings you have before they ask about your dreams and ambitions.
I told George I didn’t know, which was faster and safer than the true explanation, which involves a lot of rubbish about becoming a rich and famous actress with my own private jet who somehow becomes really influential in world politics and marries a nice boy and buys a goldfish named Walter, then gives all her money to charity. I thought George might find it strange that I had picked out a name for my future goldfish when I didn’t even know whether I wanted kids yet. Not only that, but like I said, who says George got to know, anyway? Just because his mom and my mom went to college together and then moved to the same town and invited each other to Fourth of July and Christmas parties, George and I were supposed to be old buds.
His name isn’t George, really. It’s Mike. But he doesn’t look like a Mike to me, so I changed it to George in my head. We were driving to Ithaca College together. I wanted to take English and Theatre classes and learn to write plays. George wanted to be a famous composer and then probably write ballets for skinny girls who had known what they wanted to do since they were six.
Half an hour into the ride, we had exhausted most small talk opportunities when George looked at me and said, “Do you have a boyfriend?”
I never know if I should lie or not when boys ask that question. Deciding quickly that George didn’t have any ulterior motives, I responded, “No.”
George nodded and glanced around at his mirrors before saying, “I don’t have a girlfriend, either.”
I made an “mmm” noise and continued looking out the window. There was another long pause, during which I remembered the last time this boy had thought we were friends. We were in the sixth grade and I was sitting with some girls in our Tech class. We were talking over our worksheets and probably giggling a lot. George came over and sat with us.
Present George was thinking out loud. “Everyone says it’s a really hard music program. I probably won’t have any time to meet women. Sucks.”
I said something noncommittal like, “You never know.”
I remembered what he had done in 6th grade tech after he came to sit with us.
“I farted,” he said, looking directly in my face.
All the girls had looked at me, disgusted. I was embarrassed but somehow couldn’t open my mouth to explain that this freak was not my friend. They moved to a different table, giggling. Then they wrote me a note that said, “Dear Casey, Mike Saunders is gross. Do you like him?” The teacher yelled at me for passing notes before I could write them a reply.
“Hey, are you okay?” George’s voice jolted me back to the interior of his Toyota Corolla with its moldy cup holders littered with change and rugs covered in sticky Coke cans.
“Yeah, just thinking.”
He nodded. “ I know what you mean. I have no idea what this place is going to be like now that we actually live there.”
“I wasn’t really thinking about that, actually.”
“No?”
I didn’t answer.
“Do you mind if I turn on the radio?”
“No, it’s fine.”
He turned up a station.
“Do you like this music? I can change it.”
What is it with the person who is driving always feeling like they are responsible for the entertainment of the passenger?
I fidgeted and answered, “I really don’t care.”
“Okay.”
Two miles later, George pulled into a rest stop.
“Sorry, I just realized I didn’t get enough gas and it’s probably cheaper on this side of the border.”
Again, George’s voice pulled me out of my reverie.
“Yeah, it’s cool.” I wanted to get out of the car. “I’m gonna go use the bathroom.”
“Okay,” George replied, putting the car in park.
As soon as I heard the car’s locks click, I jumped out, straightening my clothes. I walked briskly up to the building, its large sunglasses display throwing the sun into my eyes, which seemed like rigging the system to me.
After I had finished in the bathroom, I dawdled outside the little tourist shop, looking at t-shirts with road maps on them. When I got back outside, I walked toward the gas pumps, then stopped as I realized George’s car wasn’t there.
“Casey! Hey, Casey!” I heard him calling me. I turned to see George standing by his car in another lot, talking to an unshaven guy carrying an army duffel and a backpack. I walked toward them, apprehensive.
“Hey,” I said, looking at the pair of them.
“Hi, I’m Jesse,” the scruffy guy said, holding out his hand. I shook it, dim realization spreading through my brain. I looked at George, thinking, this better be your cousin.
“Hey, Jesse needs a ride. He’s actually headed toward Ithaca himself, how convenient is that?” George grinned while he rambled. I was really starting to hate him.
“Mike, the car’s pretty full,” I said cautiously.
It was Scruffyman who answered. “That’s okay, I was just telling Mike I can ride with everything on my lap.”
Finding no objections to make, and remembering I had both my mom and 911 on speed dial, I offered to take the backseat of the car.
“There’s more leg room in front,” I pointed out, and without waiting any longer, I shoved myself in the back next to a suitcase of George’s and one of my own duffel bags.
“I hope you like the music,” George said. Scruffyman piled his stuff on his lap rather energetically and said, “Yeah, man, anything’s cool with me. I’m just glad you’re picking me up, dude.”
I thought about changing Scruffyman’s name to Mandude, but I decided against it.
“Everyone in? Seat belts? All right!” George had decided to get really enthusiastic about our road trip, apparently, which was ridiculous, as the whole thing was so obviously going downhill.
“So, where are you coming from?” George asked Scruffymandude.
“Oh, you know, I was in Rochester for a while, then Mexico, then Florida, but there were too many old people there, man, so now I’m going back to Ithaca.”
“Wow, man, that’s pretty cool. So you grew up in Ithaca?” I found myself wondering why George was so polite.
“Nah dude, I grew up in Tennessee. Well, Tennesee and then Westchester.”
“So you’re rich?” I heard myself ask the question before I even stopped to think whether it was appropriate.
Scruffy actually turned his neck all the way around to look at me.
“No, I got sent to live with my auntie and uncle after my other auntie and uncle decided it would be a good experience for me. None of them are rich, but they wanted me to be.”
“Oh,” I said. I felt my body relaxing against my will as I started to believe he wouldn’t kill George and drive me somewhere no one could hear me scream.
“That’s okay,” Scruffyman said, taking my silence as apologetic. “I’m an orphan, but it’s no big deal. My mom’s siblings have been taking care of me since I was a little kid. I got used to moving around a lot. I started community college near Ithaca, but I didn’t like it, so I decided to do some traveling-- Oh, I’m sorry, man, you didn’t ask for my life story.”
Despite the warnings of my conscience about this guy possibly making up the whole thing and just getting me comfortable to rob me of all my money and possessions after raping and killing me, I was getting curious to hear about all the traveling he had done. I’d only been outside the United States once, and everyone always told me Niagara Falls, Canada doesn’t count.
George had started to ask Scruffy a question, but I cut in.
“Are you going back to school now?”
Scruffy raised his hands up by his face in a “Who knows?” gesture that would have been comical if I wasn’t afraid of him.
“I’m thinking about it. Think I’d like to be a lawyer, man.”
I must have looked shocked, because George grinned at my expression in the rearview mirror. “You surprised or something, Casey?” I ignored him.
“So, where do you get all this money from? To travel?” I demanded, determinedly looking at Scruffy.
“Oh, you know, dude, odd jobs,” Scruffyman said airily.
“No, I don’t know, dude. What kinds of jobs?” Maybe his calling me dude had set me off again, but all the stories I’d ever heard about hitchhikers involved knives and bodybags. I ignored the fact that George’s perpetual smile had been replaced by a furrowed brow. It looked like he thought I was being rude. Me, rude, when he had invited a random hitchhiker into our car without asking me. I was a thin eighteen-year-old girl without the faintest knowledge of self defense and a lot of explicit childhood advice about not talking to strangers ringing in my mind.
Scruffy turned around to look at me again. I shrank back a little, determinedly making eye contact.
“I worked at Burger King all through high school. And I babysat for my aunt and uncle. They have little kids. I saved pretty much all of it. How about you? Casey, right? Do you have a job?”
“I used to bag groceries. I quit.”
“You quit bagging groceries?”
I hated telling this story. “Yeah, I didn’t talk much, and they hired another Casey at the same time who had a mental disability. They got confused and started treating me like a moron, only I thought they were just being sarcastic-- hey! It’s not funny!”
Scruffymoron had started cracking up and George was snickering along with them.
“No, no, please don’t stop. That’s hilarious.”
“That was it,” I said shortly, going back to staring out the window. How could I have thought this guy was dangerous? This immature jerk who was just getting a ride to finish up his damn associate’s degree and went to Mexico with money from Burger King, probably to buy Mexican marijuana --
“Casey, you’re funny. Mike, she’s funny, isn’t she?” Scruffy-the-idiot cut off the silent rant I had been directing at the back of his head.
Usually, I liked being called funny. It didn’t happen much, and it usually didn’t happen when I was in a horrible mood and sitting behind a possible serial killer and Mike Saunders, packed in with boxes and bags, feeling like everything in the car was trying to smother me with my own assumptions.
I settled in against the door, tuning in and out of the animated conversation that was taking place in front of me. George asked Scruffy about good bars in Ithaca. I dimly recalled hearing that George didn’t party in high school, and vague annoyance at this line of questioning popped up in my brain. How did Mike Saunders dare to change when I had decided what to think of him six years ago?
The sun had started to disappear when the car made a sudden hard jerk to the right.
“Hey, hey, steady!” Scruffy shouted.
George was hunched in his seat. “Sorry, guys, I feel a little -- oh, shit.”
He pulled over just in time to jump out of the car and vomit on the side of the road. Scared, I got out of the car. I immediately regretted this decision and averted my eyes from the spot where George was now bent over double, hands on the knees of his jeans.
Looking around, I spotted some paper towels sticking out of a box in the back. I lunged for them and started ripping them off and handing them to Scruffy.
“Here, give him these. Help him wipe up.” Scruffyman took the towels without complaint and handed them to George. I got back out of the car, looking up cautiously.
“Hey, Mike, do you feel better?” I asked, unsure.
He nodded numbly as he wiped his mouth with one hand, his body still bent like he’d been punched in the stomach. We stood there for a couple of minutes.
“Hey, do you want me to drive?” I offered.
“He doesn’t want to get in the car again that fast, are you crazy?” Scruffy said to me. I looked at him, then back at George.
“Mike, we can sit here for a bit if you want,” I started.
“No, no, it’s fine. I feel better. Sorry. I should have said something, but I didn’t think it was that bad. I’ve been feeling nauseous for a bit.”
“No, it’s fine. Don’t worry about it. Just get in the back and rest your head.”
We got him some water and settled him in the back with a bag and some towels.
I had been driving for about twenty minutes when Scruffy said quietly to me,
“It’s good how you took care of Mike.”
“Thanks,” I said, a little taken aback that he had broken our silence.
“So, do you know what you want to do in college yet?”
“You know, why does everyone always ask that question? It’s not like I know, and why should you assume that I’m going to tell you! I mean --”
“Hey, relax, it was just a question.” Scruffy looked a little alarmed.
I stared at him. “Do I scare you or something?”
“What? I don’t know, you’re a little intimidating. Why?”
I had to remind myself to keep my eyes on the road and my mirrors.
“No reason.” I paused, wrestling with myself. “I don’t know. I was thinking about majoring in theatre.”
“Oh yeah? Did you do plays in high school?” Scruffy seemed not to be bothered by my disgruntled tone.
“Yes.”
“Anything good?”
I considered. “I don’t know what you would think is good,” I admitted.
He laughed. “Well, I love that one show. Fiddler on the Roof. It’s pretty awesome.”
I had to look at him. “Really? You like Fiddler? I was in that once.”
“Oh yeah? What part?”
“I played Chava, the --
“--the youngest daughter, yeah. I like her. She doesn’t take any crap. Like you.”
I grinned at him despite myself.
“What’s your favorite show, man?” he asked. It struck me how relaxed he looked, sitting in a stranger’s car without trying to control anything, simply going with the flow.
“Um, I really like 42nd Street. But also this show John and Jen -- have you heard of it?”
“No. Is it a musical?”
“Yeah,” I said. Shows and composers made up one of my favorite subjects, and Scruffy proved to know plenty about them. The conversation carried us through a couple of hours, until there was some movement in the backseat.
I immediately glanced in the mirror. “Do you need me to pull over?” I asked.
“No, no, I’m okay,” George grunted. “What are you guys talking about?”
“Theatre stuff,” I answered. “Why, George?”
“What?”
“Oh, uh-- yeah, I decided to call you George.” I hoped he wouldn’t think I was weird.
“Oh. Okay.”
Scruffy stared at me. “Why?” He looked at me like I was crazy.
I glanced at him. Then, out of nowhere, I couldn’t stop laughing. I had no idea how it started, but suddenly everything was funny. Both of the boys were staring at me. Then, miraculously, they were laughing too. I could hardly see the road for tears, but I couldn’t stop laughing in this car with George Saunders and Jesse the Hitchhiker.
After a while, when George had fallen back asleep and our laughter had faded to a general air of relaxed friendliness, Scruffy turned to me and said, “So what was so funny?”
I didn’t know how to tell him that somebody who I had thought was going to end my life mere hours before had suddenly given me the urge to get two goldfish when I grew up, and name one of them Scruffy.
“Oh, nothing really.” I smiled at him. “So, Jesse, where are you living in Ithaca?”